Where does Vitals rank in AI search for cosmetic surgery in New York City?

Vitals ranks #120 of 1,051 cosmetic surgery firms measured in New York City by AI recommendation share (0.8% across ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini, and Perplexity), based on the August 2026 snapshot.

Which AI assistants cite Vitals?

In the current snapshot, Vitals was named by 3 of the 4 AI assistants tested (ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini, Perplexity). The per-assistant breakdown is published at https://viclaro.app/leaderboards/nyc/medical/cosmetic-surgery/vitals.

Is Vitals recommended by ChatGPT?

AI recommendations vary by assistant and prompt. The Viclaro Atlas profile at https://viclaro.app/leaderboards/nyc/medical/cosmetic-surgery/vitals shows the per-assistant breakdown, every recorded citation, and the specific buyer scenarios where each AI named this firm.

New York City · Cosmetic Surgery

Vitals

How to read this firm's data

Header tiles

Rank: Position among firms named in the category's latest scan.
Response mention rate: The percentage of latest-snapshot AI responses that named this business. ±X is the 95% confidence margin.
Cited by: How many of the four AI assistants named this firm at least once.
Tier: 🟢 consensus · 🟡 mid-tier · ⚪ sample-limited.

Breakdowns + log

90-day trend: Each dot is one category snapshot.
Per-AI breakdown: Responses from each assistant that named this firm.
By question type: Citations grouped by what the buyer was asking.
Citation log: Every recorded instance where an AI named this firm.

Full methodology →

Rank

#120

of 1051 firms

Response mention rate

0.8%

±0.5% (95% confidence)

Cited by

3/4

✓ Claude ✓ ChatGPT ✗ Gemini ✗ Perplexity

Tier

⚪ Sample-limited

9 citations · consensus 1.73

Per-AI breakdown

Empty cards = that AI assistant doesn't surface this firm. A firm cited by only one AI is likely invisible to most buyers.

Claude

mentions

ChatGPT

mentions

Gemini

mentions

Perplexity

mentions

By question type

Citations split by buyer-intent category. Empty rows = AI doesn't think of this firm when buyers ask that kind of question.

Validation

9 mentions

Citation log

9 mentions recorded for this business in the latest snapshot.

Where Vitals is winning + missing, prompt-by-prompt

136 of 141 ranking-layer buyer prompts don't cite this firm. The three firms cited most on each missing prompt are the competitors closing that gap. Prompt text is redacted (see methodology §8) — buckets show the shape of the gap.

136 missing prompts Sorted by competitor citation weight

P-001

Advice

Firms cited on this prompt:

Dr. Andrew Jacono ×8 Sherrell Aston ×4 David Hidalgo ×4

P-002

Decision

Firms cited on this prompt:

Dr. Andrew Jacono ×8 Sherrell Aston ×4 Dr. Sam Rizk, MD ×3

P-003

Decision

Firms cited on this prompt:

Dr. Andrew Jacono ×8 FaceTite ×4 Dr. Dara Liotta ×4

P-004

Decision

Firms cited on this prompt:

Dr. Andrew Jacono ×8 Sherrell Aston ×3 Dr. David Rapaport ×2

P-005

Learning

Firms cited on this prompt:

SMAS Facelift ×8 Dr. Richard Swift, MD: Plastic Surgeon NYC, Buccal Fat Removal, Deep Plane Facelift and Chin Liposuction ×7 Mini Facelift ×7

P-006

Learning

Firms cited on this prompt:

RealSelf ×8 Dr. David Shafer ×6 Sherrell Aston ×5

P-007

Learning

Firms cited on this prompt:

New York City ×8 Miami ×7 Beverly Hills ×7

P-008

Learning

Firms cited on this prompt:

American Board of Plastic Surgery ×8 American Board of Cosmetic Surgery (ABCS) ×8 American Board of Medical Specialties ×7

P-009

Situation

Firms cited on this prompt:

Dr. Douglas Steinbrech ×8 Dr. David Shafer ×6 LARA DEVGAN, MD, PLLC ×2

P-010

Situation

Firms cited on this prompt:

Dr. Andrew Jacono ×8 Sherrell Aston ×6 Dr. Sam Rizk, MD ×4

P-011

Constraints

Firms cited on this prompt:

Columbia ×7 NYU Langone Health ×6 Mount Sinai Health System ×5

P-012

Follow Up

Firms cited on this prompt:

Aetna ×7 Dr. Nolan Karp ×4 NYU Langone Plastic Surgery ×4

P-013

Situation

Firms cited on this prompt:

Dr. Andrew Jacono ×7 Dr. Sam Rizk, MD ×3 Dr. Stafford Broumand ×3

P-014

Situation

Firms cited on this prompt:

Dr. Andrew Jacono ×7 Dr. Lara Devgan ×3 Dr. David B. Rosenberg, MD ×3

P-015

Situation

Firms cited on this prompt:

Dr. Adam Kolker ×7 Dr. Nolan Karp ×5 Dr. Stafford Broumand ×4

+ 121 more missing prompts. The full list — with the verbatim prompt text and every cited firm — is part of a Viclaro audit.

5 winning prompts Prompts where AI cited this firm

W-001

Validation

Also cited on this prompt:

Dr. Marcus Chen ×7 New York State ×7 American Board of Plastic Surgery ×4

W-002

Validation

Also cited on this prompt:

New York State ×6 David Hidalgo ×4 Sherrell Aston ×4

W-003

Validation

Also cited on this prompt:

American Board of Plastic Surgery ×6 RealSelf ×6 Healthgrades ×3

W-004

Validation

Also cited on this prompt:

Dr. Adaeze Okafor ×6 RealSelf ×4 Board-Certified Plastic Surgeons (ABPS) ×3

W-005

Validation

Also cited on this prompt:

Zocdoc ×5 Healthgrades ×4 Vitals ×4

Peer firms in New York City cosmetic surgery

Other firms ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini, and Perplexity name in this category.

Dr. Andrew Jacono

21.2% share · 4/4 AI

David Hidalgo

15.8% share · 4/4 AI

Sherrell Aston

13.7% share · 4/4 AI

Dr. David Shafer

12.8% share · 4/4 AI

Dr. Sam Rizk, MD

12.4% share · 4/4 AI

Dr. Adam Kolker

12.0% share · 4/4 AI

NYU Langone Plastic Surgery

9.8% share · 4/4 AI

Dr. Stafford Broumand

9.6% share · 4/4 AI

See the full Cosmetic Surgery ranking →

Want to climb the rankings?

We'll show you the exact content competitors published that earned their citations — and the specific answer blocks + schema markup for Vitals to outrank them.

Get a full audit →