New York City · CPA & Tax
WithumSmith+Brown
Unverified listing
AI assistants named this firm, but Viclaro doesn't yet have a verified business record for it — the ranking reflects citations only. If this is your firm, claim the listing below and we'll reach out from support@viclaro.app to verify.
WithumSmith+Brown was not cited in the most recent scan.
No AI assistant named this firm in response to any of the buyer questions in the latest run.
Longitudinal evidence · all retained runs
All-time Atlas record
Observed Aug 21, 2026–Aug 21, 2026
Responses analyzed
2,256
Responses naming firm
66
Lifetime mention rate
2.9%
Published snapshots ranked
0
These totals span every retained response for this exact city and category, including historical prompt-set versions. They describe accumulated evidence, not the firm's current rank. The cards above and per-AI breakdown use only the dated current snapshot; the history chart compares compatible published snapshots.
Where AI cites them
Across every retained response in this category, 66 distinct AI responses named WithumSmith+Brown. Grouped by assistant family and by the buyer question that triggered the citation.
By AI assistant
By buyer question
-
×3
law_firm_partner_first_k1
Named in 3 responses · Claude · ChatGPT
-
anthropic/claude-sonnet-4.6
**Firms that specialize in this exact situation:** - **Eisner Advisory Group** – heavy NYC professional services partnership tax, lots of law/finance firm partners - **Anchin, Block & Anchin** – know...
-
openai/gpt-4o
1. **WithumSmith+Brown** - Known for their expertise in handling tax issues for law firm partners, including K-1 complexities and estimated payments. 2. **Marks Paneth LLP** - Specializes in accounti...
-
openai/gpt-4o
Consider reaching out to the following firms or professionals for specialized tax advice for new law-firm partners in NYC: 1. **Anchin, Block & Anchin LLP** - Known for their expertise in servicing l...
-
-
×3
services_business_owner_50m
Named in 3 responses · Claude · Perplexity
-
anthropic/claude-sonnet-4.6
For NYC at your size and profile, the firms that live exactly in that tier: **Grant Thornton** – Strong middle-market services practice, good NYC presence, genuinely competitive with Big Four on tech...
-
anthropic/claude-sonnet-4.6
For NYC at your size and profile, the firms that genuinely sit in that tier: **Grant Thornton** – Strongest bench of the "next tier" firms; good NYC presence, handles complexity at your scale well....
-
perplexity/sonar
Yes — in NYC, the “between regional and Big Four” lane is typically **large national middle-market firms** and **larger New York-based advisory/accounting firms** with deeper tax, audit, transaction,...
-
-
×3
ecommerce_amazon_seller_growth
Named in 3 responses · Claude · ChatGPT
-
anthropic/claude-sonnet-4.6
At $4.6M with multi-state nexus across 15 locations (14 Amazon FBA states + Nevada 3PL), you have real complexity: inventory-based nexus triggers, potential P.L. 86-272 limitations, Amazon's 1099-K re...
-
anthropic/claude-sonnet-4.6
At $4.6M with Amazon nexus in 14 states plus a Nevada 3PL, you have real complexity: economic nexus thresholds, FBA inventory-triggered physical nexus, potential marketplace facilitator nuances, COGS/...
-
openai/gpt-4o
1. **Citrin Cooperman** - Known for their expertise in e-commerce and digital retail accounting, especially for mid-sized businesses. 2. **Eide Bailly LLP** - Offers specialized services for e-commer...
-
-
×3
real_estate_ltr_portfolio_situation
Named in 3 responses · ChatGPT · Perplexity
-
openai/gpt-4o
1. **Marks Paneth LLP** - Known for expertise in real estate tax planning and passive activity loss strategies. 2. **Withum** - Offers comprehensive tax planning services, including strategies for rea...
-
openai/gpt-4o
1. **Marks Paneth LLP** - Known for expertise in real estate tax planning and understanding of passive activity loss rules. 2. **Friedman LLP** - Offers tailored strategies for real estate investors,...
-
perplexity/sonar
- **Reed Corporation Tax** — NYC CPA firm that markets heavily to real estate investors and landlords; good fit for modeling passive-loss carryforwards, REP status, and the §469 planning levers for hi...
-
-
×2
rsu_iso_tech_worker
Named in 2 responses · Claude
-
anthropic/claude-sonnet-4.6
## Your Core Problems **1. RSU withholding gap** — Employers default to 22% supplemental rate on RSU vesting; your marginal rate is almost certainly 37% federal + 3.876% NYC + 6.85% NY state. That sp...
-
anthropic/claude-sonnet-4.6
## Your Core Problems **1. Withholding gap** — RSU supplemental withholding is capped at 22% federal (37% marginal rate means you're perpetually short ~15 points on every vest). Fix: file a new W-4 w...
-
-
×2
selling_business_next_year_deal_cpa
Named in 2 responses · Claude · ChatGPT
-
anthropic/claude-sonnet-4.6
NYC CPAs/firms strong on M&A deal structure at your size: **Boutique/Mid-Size (often better attention at $14M)** - **Anchin, Block & Anchin** – strong NYC closely-held business M&A tax, good partner...
-
openai/gpt-4o
1. **EisnerAmper LLP** - Known for comprehensive transaction advisory services, including tax structuring for business sales. 2. **Marcum LLP** - Offers expertise in tax planning and structuring for m...
-
-
×2
is_cpa_gaslighting_me
Named in 2 responses · ChatGPT
-
openai/gpt-4o
Your financial situation involves multiple components that can be complex: RSUs (restricted stock units), an S-corp, rental property, and a K-1 from a syndication. These elements require careful tax p...
-
openai/gpt-4o
Your situation involves multiple layers of tax complexity, including RSUs, an S-corp, rental property, and a K-1 from a syndication. It may warrant a more specialized approach. Consider consulting: 1...
-
-
×2
w2_only_but_complex_rsu
Named in 2 responses · ChatGPT
-
openai/gpt-4o
1. **Anchin, Block & Anchin LLP** - Known for handling complex individual tax situations, especially with equity compensation. 2. **Marks Paneth LLP** - Offers personalized tax services for individual...
-
openai/gpt-4o
1. **R&G Brenner Income Tax** - Known for handling complex individual tax situations with a focus on RSUs and stock options. 2. **Marks Paneth LLP** - Offers personalized services for individuals with...
-
Citation log
66 distinct AI responses named this business in the current snapshot. This log is intentionally snapshot-scoped; the all-time record above summarizes the complete longitudinal corpus.
Where WithumSmith+Brown is winning + missing, prompt-by-prompt
95 of 141 ranking-layer buyer prompts don't cite this firm. The table lists the three most-cited firms for each missing prompt. Prompt text is redacted (see prompt-set methodology).
P-002
Situation
Firms cited on this prompt:
P-003
Learning
Firms cited on this prompt:
P-004
Decision
Firms cited on this prompt:
P-005
Validation
Firms cited on this prompt:
P-006
Validation
Firms cited on this prompt:
P-007
Validation
Firms cited on this prompt:
P-008
Validation
Firms cited on this prompt:
P-009
Validation
Firms cited on this prompt:
P-010
Situation
Firms cited on this prompt:
P-011
Decision
Firms cited on this prompt:
P-012
Decision
Firms cited on this prompt:
P-014
Crisis
Firms cited on this prompt:
P-015
Crisis
Firms cited on this prompt:
46 winning prompts Prompts where AI cited this firm
W-001
Validation
Also cited on this prompt:
W-002
Situation
Also cited on this prompt:
W-003
Decision
Also cited on this prompt:
W-004
Decision
Also cited on this prompt:
W-005
Situation
Also cited on this prompt:
W-006
Advice
Also cited on this prompt:
W-007
Follow Up
Also cited on this prompt:
W-008
Constraints
Also cited on this prompt:
W-009
Situation
Also cited on this prompt:
W-010
Crisis
Also cited on this prompt:
Peer firms in New York City cpa & tax
Other firms ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini, and Perplexity name in this category.
#1
Braj Aggarwal, CPA, P.C. - Trusted CPA & Accountant in NYC
6.3% response mention rate · 4/4 AI
#2
Bench
4.3% response mention rate · 4/4 AI
#3
Deloitte Private
4.1% response mention rate · 4/4 AI
#4
George Dimov CPA
3.9% response mention rate · 4/4 AI
#5
Kruze
3.6% response mention rate · 4/4 AI
#6
Nonprofit Accountant New York City
3.6% response mention rate · 3/4 AI
#7
Reed Corporation CPA Firm
3.5% response mention rate · 1/4 AI
#8
Gary Mehta, CPA, EA : Accountant of New York and Beyond
3.2% response mention rate · 4/4 AI
Field notes on reading these rankings
All notes →How to Read AI Search Rankings (Beyond Vanity Metrics)
AI search rankings measure how often assistants like ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini, and Perplexity name a business when a buyer asks who to hire. Read for share of vo...
How to Write Content That AI Assistants Actually Cite
Content that AI assistants cite looks different from content designed for humans or Google. It answers the buyer's exact question in a single quotable sentence,...
Why AI Recommendations Change Between Runs (and When a Change Is Real)
An assistant is not a laminated directory. Search results move, generated wording varies, and a tiny prompt edit can change the shortlist. The answer is not to...
Want to climb the rankings?
Compare the sources and page content associated with citations in this category.
Get a full audit →