New York City · CPA & Tax

WithumSmith+Brown

Weekly at most. One-click unsubscribe.

Unverified listing

AI assistants named this firm, but Viclaro doesn't yet have a verified business record for it — the ranking reflects citations only. If this is your firm, claim the listing below and we'll reach out from support@viclaro.app to verify.

We don't share this. Used only to verify the listing.

WithumSmith+Brown was not cited in the most recent scan.

No AI assistant named this firm in response to any of the buyer questions in the latest run.

Longitudinal evidence · all retained runs

All-time Atlas record

Observed Aug 21, 2026–Aug 21, 2026

Responses analyzed

2,256

Responses naming firm

66

Lifetime mention rate

2.9%

Published snapshots ranked

0

These totals span every retained response for this exact city and category, including historical prompt-set versions. They describe accumulated evidence, not the firm's current rank. The cards above and per-AI breakdown use only the dated current snapshot; the history chart compares compatible published snapshots.

Where AI cites them

Across every retained response in this category, 66 distinct AI responses named WithumSmith+Brown. Grouped by assistant family and by the buyer question that triggered the citation.

By AI assistant

Claude
10 citations
ChatGPT
50 citations
Gemini
0 citations
Perplexity
6 citations

By buyer question

  • law_firm_partner_first_k1

    Named in 3 responses · Claude · ChatGPT

    ×3
    • anthropic/claude-sonnet-4.6

      **Firms that specialize in this exact situation:** - **Eisner Advisory Group** – heavy NYC professional services partnership tax, lots of law/finance firm partners - **Anchin, Block & Anchin** – know...

    • openai/gpt-4o

      1. **WithumSmith+Brown** - Known for their expertise in handling tax issues for law firm partners, including K-1 complexities and estimated payments. 2. **Marks Paneth LLP** - Specializes in accounti...

    • openai/gpt-4o

      Consider reaching out to the following firms or professionals for specialized tax advice for new law-firm partners in NYC: 1. **Anchin, Block & Anchin LLP** - Known for their expertise in servicing l...

  • services_business_owner_50m

    Named in 3 responses · Claude · Perplexity

    ×3
    • anthropic/claude-sonnet-4.6

      For NYC at your size and profile, the firms that live exactly in that tier: **Grant Thornton** – Strong middle-market services practice, good NYC presence, genuinely competitive with Big Four on tech...

    • anthropic/claude-sonnet-4.6

      For NYC at your size and profile, the firms that genuinely sit in that tier: **Grant Thornton** – Strongest bench of the "next tier" firms; good NYC presence, handles complexity at your scale well....

    • perplexity/sonar

      Yes — in NYC, the “between regional and Big Four” lane is typically **large national middle-market firms** and **larger New York-based advisory/accounting firms** with deeper tax, audit, transaction,...

  • ecommerce_amazon_seller_growth

    Named in 3 responses · Claude · ChatGPT

    ×3
    • anthropic/claude-sonnet-4.6

      At $4.6M with multi-state nexus across 15 locations (14 Amazon FBA states + Nevada 3PL), you have real complexity: inventory-based nexus triggers, potential P.L. 86-272 limitations, Amazon's 1099-K re...

    • anthropic/claude-sonnet-4.6

      At $4.6M with Amazon nexus in 14 states plus a Nevada 3PL, you have real complexity: economic nexus thresholds, FBA inventory-triggered physical nexus, potential marketplace facilitator nuances, COGS/...

    • openai/gpt-4o

      1. **Citrin Cooperman** - Known for their expertise in e-commerce and digital retail accounting, especially for mid-sized businesses. 2. **Eide Bailly LLP** - Offers specialized services for e-commer...

  • real_estate_ltr_portfolio_situation

    Named in 3 responses · ChatGPT · Perplexity

    ×3
    • openai/gpt-4o

      1. **Marks Paneth LLP** - Known for expertise in real estate tax planning and passive activity loss strategies. 2. **Withum** - Offers comprehensive tax planning services, including strategies for rea...

    • openai/gpt-4o

      1. **Marks Paneth LLP** - Known for expertise in real estate tax planning and understanding of passive activity loss rules. 2. **Friedman LLP** - Offers tailored strategies for real estate investors,...

    • perplexity/sonar

      - **Reed Corporation Tax** — NYC CPA firm that markets heavily to real estate investors and landlords; good fit for modeling passive-loss carryforwards, REP status, and the §469 planning levers for hi...

  • rsu_iso_tech_worker

    Named in 2 responses · Claude

    ×2
    • anthropic/claude-sonnet-4.6

      ## Your Core Problems **1. RSU withholding gap** — Employers default to 22% supplemental rate on RSU vesting; your marginal rate is almost certainly 37% federal + 3.876% NYC + 6.85% NY state. That sp...

    • anthropic/claude-sonnet-4.6

      ## Your Core Problems **1. Withholding gap** — RSU supplemental withholding is capped at 22% federal (37% marginal rate means you're perpetually short ~15 points on every vest). Fix: file a new W-4 w...

  • selling_business_next_year_deal_cpa

    Named in 2 responses · Claude · ChatGPT

    ×2
    • anthropic/claude-sonnet-4.6

      NYC CPAs/firms strong on M&A deal structure at your size: **Boutique/Mid-Size (often better attention at $14M)** - **Anchin, Block & Anchin** – strong NYC closely-held business M&A tax, good partner...

    • openai/gpt-4o

      1. **EisnerAmper LLP** - Known for comprehensive transaction advisory services, including tax structuring for business sales. 2. **Marcum LLP** - Offers expertise in tax planning and structuring for m...

  • is_cpa_gaslighting_me

    Named in 2 responses · ChatGPT

    ×2
    • openai/gpt-4o

      Your financial situation involves multiple components that can be complex: RSUs (restricted stock units), an S-corp, rental property, and a K-1 from a syndication. These elements require careful tax p...

    • openai/gpt-4o

      Your situation involves multiple layers of tax complexity, including RSUs, an S-corp, rental property, and a K-1 from a syndication. It may warrant a more specialized approach. Consider consulting: 1...

  • w2_only_but_complex_rsu

    Named in 2 responses · ChatGPT

    ×2
    • openai/gpt-4o

      1. **Anchin, Block & Anchin LLP** - Known for handling complex individual tax situations, especially with equity compensation. 2. **Marks Paneth LLP** - Offers personalized tax services for individual...

    • openai/gpt-4o

      1. **R&G Brenner Income Tax** - Known for handling complex individual tax situations with a focus on RSUs and stock options. 2. **Marks Paneth LLP** - Offers personalized services for individuals with...

Citation log

66 distinct AI responses named this business in the current snapshot. This log is intentionally snapshot-scoped; the all-time record above summarizes the complete longitudinal corpus.

Where WithumSmith+Brown is winning + missing, prompt-by-prompt

95 of 141 ranking-layer buyer prompts don't cite this firm. The table lists the three most-cited firms for each missing prompt. Prompt text is redacted (see prompt-set methodology).

95 missing prompts Sorted by competitor citation weight

P-001

Follow Up

Firms cited on this prompt:

P-002

Situation

P-004

Decision

P-007

Validation

P-012

Decision

P-013

Validation

Firms cited on this prompt:

+ 80 more missing prompts. The full list — with the verbatim prompt text and every cited firm — is part of a Viclaro audit.
46 winning prompts Prompts where AI cited this firm

W-001

Validation

W-002

Situation

W-003

Decision

W-004

Decision

W-005

Situation

W-006

Advice

W-008

Constraints

W-009

Situation

W-010

Crisis

Peer firms in New York City cpa & tax

Other firms ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini, and Perplexity name in this category.

See the full CPA & Tax ranking →

Want to climb the rankings?

Compare the sources and page content associated with citations in this category.

Get a full audit →

Rank-change alerts

Watch this firm

Get an email when this firm moves in the ChatGPT / Claude / Gemini / Perplexity leaderboard. Weekly at most; usually less.

We only email you when the ranking actually changes. One-click unsubscribe on every message. We won't add you to any other list — this is the alert, not a funnel.

8,975

Firms ranked now

3,560

Practitioners ever named

12

Public verticals

27,066

All-time AI responses